Current Issue
Political Dynasties and Service Delivery: Evidence from Rural Health Clinics in Punjab Pakistan
Faiz Ur Rehman and Noman Ahmad
Published:July-Dec, 2025
Research suggests that politics plays a pivotal role in public service provision in
contexts of scarce resources. However, there is limited evidence available on how dynastic
politicians influence public service delivery. We examine this question in the context of the
health sector in Punjab, Pakistan. By employing a representative sample of rural health
clinics, we develop measures to capture doctors’ outcomes at the clinic level. These data are
then matched with provincial constituency-level data to study the impact of having a
dynastic member of the parliament (MP) on doctors’ assignment, attendance, and tenure in
their respective constituencies. Our findings show that having a dynastic MP has no
discernible impact on the assignment and attendance of doctors. However, clinics in
constituencies with a dynastic MP have relatively experienced doctors. Furthermore, our
suggestive evidence from the Pakistan Household and Living Measurement Survey (PSLM)
shows that individuals living in districts with a higher proportion of dynastic MPs report
lower improvements in clinic services and are less satisfied with those services. Our main
findings remain robust to various alternative explanations.
KEYWORDS:
Political Dynasties, Public Goods Provision, Pakistan, PSLM.
JEL:
H51, H89.
Evaluating the Impact of Withdrawal of Telegraphic Transfer (TT) Charges Reimbursement on the Remittances from the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA)
Muhammad Omer
Published:July-Dec, 2025
The Government of Pakistan reimburses SAR 30 in Telegraphic Transfer Charges
(TTC) for every USD 100 or more transferred by a foreign MTO into the country, as
compensation for their transaction costs. In May 2020, the government removed this facility
for KSA, citing zero transaction costs announced by the KSA authorities for digital money
transfers from the kingdom. The inflow of workers’ remittances from KSA began to decrease
once KSA eased the travel ban. This paper aims to estimate the impact of the withdrawal of
TTC reimbursement on remittances flowing from KSA to Pakistan. The difference-indifference (DID) method is applied to data from July 2018 to September 2022. The estimates
indicate that this policy caused an average monthly decline in remittances from KSA
between US$ 31 million and US$ 76 million. The findings appear to be robust to various
estimation adjustments.
KEYWORDS:
Pakistan, remittance inflow, policy impact, Covid-19, panel data.
JEL:
F24, F31.
The Economic Impact of Environmental Sustainability Practices in the Hospitality Sector: A Global Review with Policy Implications for Pakistan
Kashaf Waseem
Published:July-Dec, 2025
This paper explores the economics of environmental sustainability practices in the
hospitality industry, focusing on the operational efficiency of hotels, cost-effectiveness, and
return on investment (ROI), with a specific focus on the emerging market in Pakistan.
Results indicate that green retrofits, including LED lighting and HVAC optimization, deliver
average energy savings of 25-40 percent, payback periods of 1-5 years, and internal rate of
return (IRR) of 18. Food-waste minimization systems, such as Winnow and Leanpath, have
a 7:1 ROI in two years, and water recycling systems reduce consumption by 20-30 percent
in less than four years. Hotels that operate sustainably worldwide show reduced operating
costs by up to 30 percent and premium rates of 5-15 percent, based on customer willingness
to pay higher rates in environmentally conscious hotels. The article presents a combination
of comparative ROI modeling, policy SWOT analysis, and cross-regional benchmarking to
assess the feasibility and scalability of green investments. By linking economic indicators to
environmental performance, this research confirms that sustainability practices are not only
environmentally advantageous but also economically strategic.
KEYWORDS:
Pakistan, remittance inflow, policy impact, Covid-19, panel data.
JEL:
E22, F64, O13.
Measuring Availability of Resources: A Case Study of Selected CPI Items in Pakistan
Nimra Hamayun, Hafiz Rizwan Ahmad and Muhammad Munawar
Published:July-Dec, 2025
It is widely believed that resources are becoming scarcer, and measuring their availability is crucial for efficient allocation. This study measures the availability and
affordability of essential items in Pakistan before and after COVID-19. Time Price, Price
Elasticity of Population (PEP), and Simon Abundance Index (SAI) are calculated to analyze
thirty-nine items from Pakistan's CPI basket. The findings reveal that from 2006 to 2018, the
Time Price decreased for almost all items, indicating increased affordability and resource
abundance relative to population growth. However, the COVID-19 pandemic significantly
increased the Time Prices of essential commodities, making them less affordable and less
abundant. Policymakers are advised to adjust wages to maintain purchasing power and to
adopt resilient strategies to ensure Pakistan is well prepared for such crises.
KEYWORDS:
Resource abundance, time price, Simon abundance index, inflation measurement, COVID-19 impact, Pakistan.
JEL:
E31, C43, J21, O47.
